Welcome to Sphynxlair! Connect with Sphynx owners & enthusiasts around the world!

heart murmur

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
As a lot of you know, I have our boy Yoda at home. We have also just purchased a little girl to join our family :BigSmile: they are both very healthy.
The breeder has offered to give me a sphynx boy who is 12 weeks old as a freebie. The catch? He has a heart murmur. The first vet didn't pick up on it, vet 2 (she changed vet due to having to drive 4+ hours) said the murmur was substantial. Vet 3 (to get a second opinion), said the murmer wasnt too bad and he should out grow it by the time he is 6 months. They didnt grade it.
The breeder was going to keep him on as a vasectomy cat to "help out" the girls. But would much rather he be in a loving family with us. Giving him a better life is a must for her.
My long winded question is, what can the cause of the murmur be?
She's only asked me to pay for second set of needles and for him to get desexed. He's beautiful blue mink boy.
Your thoughts and advice would be great.
 

assibassi

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
5,993
Points
393
I do not know the cost of vetbills if you have a Hcm (spell) cat ? So i dont know what to tell you.
Since he has a pre existing condition, i am also not sure or pet insurance will pick him up . If you know what i mean.
Personaly if I would get offered a cat like that, I am not sure, I would get so attached to it and then having to see im suffer , if he does ? I Think it would break my heart !! But he could have a long good life too, with or without murmur. Tuff decission.
 

Caloci

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2011
Messages
4,609
Points
348
I would want to know if it was HCM or not first. For Vito yearly with a mild case of HOCM his basic med bills run me $2000/year.

~ $200 for annual check up
~ $600 per scan x 2 (this includes scan, round trip ferry, gas and my meals for the day)
~ $60/4 months x 3 for meds

That adds up to less than 2000 but some years we need shots, dental and blood work are extra

If the little guy just had a benign murmur I'd go for it. If you can afford a potentially substantial vet bill on top of your other financial commitments go for it.
 

lucylue

V.I.P Lairian
V.I.P Lairian
Joined
Dec 11, 2012
Messages
1,237
Points
158
Thats a tough question, my kitty has been sick only 7 months old. We are still not in the clear with her and I have grown so attached I honestly do not know what I am going to do if I find out she is dying. I find out more Tuesday, ugh, I just dont know if I would take a sick kitty.
 

NinaGato

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2010
Messages
6,201
Points
643
I dunno. I had a kit that his heart murmur showed up at 13 weeks and he was dead at 7 months and 19 days and it broke my heart. I also have a cat who on th 25th of June will be 13 years old and has had a murmur since I have had her from the age of one. She has had other heath issues and we have Had Ekgs every other year to keep a praised of her condion. I have had the good and bad of it woth cardiovascular cats. You have to make sure you keep their teeth clean because endocarditis is easier to set in.
 

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
It's a massive decision. He classed as a grade 3 on a scale of 1-5 so smack in the middle. The vet she took him to thinks he'll be fine. I'm so confused right now I'm going nuts.
She rang the vet back for a grade. He said 3
 
Last edited:

Lickleone

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
6,022
Points
643
For me it be easy decision the only factor would be can I afford to take care if him if his condition required it if I could it be a no brainier but that's me I'd grab him in a heart beat but a sucker for that kind of situation and I'd try my utmost to make his life as awesome as I could
 

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
For me it be easy decision the only factor would be can I afford to take care if him if his condition required it if I could it be a no brainier but that's me I'd grab him in a heart beat but a sucker for that kind of situation and I'd try my utmost to make his life as awesome as I could

So am I, so I convinced hubby dearest. All good. He is coming to live with us. We went out and bought extra everything. Then last night I got a call from the breeder saying that the vet has refused to desex him until he is 6 months old. It's illegal in Australia to sell an entire cat to a non breeder. So right now she is trying to negotiate to draw up a contract through the club to get authority for me to get him desexed here. Or at least convince her to take him to her regular vet which is 4 hours drive, one way (I'm willing to give her petrol money)
So right now it's a big waiting game.
To top it off, our girl won't be coming home for another week :Sad: due to the current vet she is using. (The same one who won't desex the boy till he's 6 months)
He hasn't new name but I don't want to say what it is yet, to not jinx myself.
 

susi794

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
13,556
Points
673
My vet refuses to desex before six months of age also. I pray the murmur is only a murmur and nothing else. Good luck and please keep us informed.
Hugs,
Susi
 

NinaGato

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2010
Messages
6,201
Points
643
Gosh Merlin came to me neutered at 12 weeks old. It was kinda nice and my vet will do boys at 2 lbs and girls at 3.5lbs
 

Nofuratu

V.I.P Lairian
V.I.P Lairian
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
1,659
Points
238
Since I have 2 cats with mumurs, both from different breeders, who both have HOCM I guess I'll pipe in....

The cat needs a scan at 1yr of age (an echocardiogram) to tell you what you need to know and the scan needs to be done by a cardiologist. In my location that costs $350 plus $100 in travel expenses or now that I have started setting up my own hcm screening clinic at a local cat show its only $200.

So you probably already know some cats can have benign murmurs without hcm, and have hcm without murmurs etc.

However, I am REALLY leery of vets diagnosing much from auscultation alone! which is why you need an echocardiogram and they say there's no point til 1yr of age for that.

My first sphynx was diagnosed with a grade 3/4 murmur at age 2. The vet was not concerned at all and we did nothing about it. I didn't know much about it all and it was presented to me as no big deal. At age 3 he had a signifigant murmur and I had an echocardiogram done with revealed moderate HCM. I was advised to do nothing and rescan in a year. At age 4 his scan revealed mod/severe HOCM. He was progressing faster than they expected and I started atenolol from my own choice. The vet said it wasn't necessary for sure, my cat was completely symptom free and it was up to me. After hearing about cats IMPROVE on atenolol I started it. At age 5 Nofuratu's mod/severe HOCM has gone back down to moderate after a year of atenolol and he has a decent prognosis....so I may have bought him a few extra years.

Another of my sphynx, Count, had a healthy heart at 5 months when he was neutered. At 1 yr of age I had an echocardiogram done on him for fun....because I set up my own clinic and the price was low and I thought it would help my breeder to have another clear scan in her lineage. It was a few months before his annual vaccines and check up so this was the first time he'd had his heart listened to since 5 months old. His murmur was signifigant, grade 4/5 and his echo revealed severe HCM. I was told to start atenolol immediately and that he would start passing out soon without meds. That's at just 1yr old. If anyone says scans at 1yr are also useless....they aren't.

After a month on atenolol I took Count to a new local vet and she listened to his heart. she told me he had a mild murmur and not to worry about it. WFT? I informed her of his severe HOCM, his echo results and meds and she told me I jumped the gun on meds and I didn't need to worry about the murmur. That is scary!!! How many other cats with murmurs has she listened to and said don't worry about it?? she didn't recommend an echo either. She also didn't take into consideration he was on atenolol for a month so his murmur would be decreased a bit because his meds are working.

So I rambled all that to you to illustrate that listening to the heart is great, and you may have good news when you get a scan that it is a benign murmur....but you really do need a scan at 1yr to figure out if its benign or not and there are some nutty vets out there telling people that severe murmurs are nothing to worry about and don't need scans.....AND both my cats showed no symptoms of HCM so don't let them tell you you don't need a scan cause he doesn't have symptoms. The benefit of a scan is it will either ease your mind and tell you its benign, or its hcm and you get him on meds that will buy you extra time. Heart meds are not expensive at all btw. Just the scan is costly and usually annual with a HCM positive cat.

Would the breeder agree to pay for his scan at 1yr of age, or split it with you? You are taking a big risk emotionally and financially and doing her a favor really....I don't expect her to cover future scans or meds, but what about the first??
 

Lickleone

Gold Lairian
Notable Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
6,022
Points
643
So am I, so I convinced hubby dearest. All good. He is coming to live with us. We went out and bought extra everything. Then last night I got a call from the breeder saying that the vet has refused to desex him until he is 6 months old. It's illegal in Australia to sell an entire cat to a non breeder. So right now she is trying to negotiate to draw up a contract through the club to get authority for me to get him desexed here. Or at least convince her to take him to her regular vet which is 4 hours drive, one way (I'm willing to give her petrol money)
So right now it's a big waiting game.
To top it off, our girl won't be coming home for another week :Sad: due to the current vet she is using. (The same one who won't desex the boy till he's 6 months)
He hasn't new name but I don't want to say what it is yet, to not jinx myself.

I'm sure both babies will bring you great joy :)
 

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
Since I have 2 cats with mumurs, both from different breeders, who both have HOCM I guess I'll pipe in....

The cat needs a scan at 1yr of age (an echocardiogram) to tell you what you need to know and the scan needs to be done by a cardiologist. In my location that costs $350 plus $100 in travel expenses or now that I have started setting up my own hcm screening clinic at a local cat show its only $200.

So you probably already know some cats can have benign murmurs without hcm, and have hcm without murmurs etc.

However, I am REALLY leery of vets diagnosing much from auscultation alone! which is why you need an echocardiogram and they say there's no point til 1yr of age for that.

My first sphynx was diagnosed with a grade 3/4 murmur at age 2. The vet was not concerned at all and we did nothing about it. I didn't know much about it all and it was presented to me as no big deal. At age 3 he had a signifigant murmur and I had an echocardiogram done with revealed moderate HCM. I was advised to do nothing and rescan in a year. At age 4 his scan revealed mod/severe HOCM. He was progressing faster than they expected and I started atenolol from my own choice. The vet said it wasn't necessary for sure, my cat was completely symptom free and it was up to me. After hearing about cats IMPROVE on atenolol I started it. At age 5 Nofuratu's mod/severe HOCM has gone back down to moderate after a year of atenolol and he has a decent prognosis....so I may have bought him a few extra years.

Another of my sphynx, Count, had a healthy heart at 5 months when he was neutered. At 1 yr of age I had an echocardiogram done on him for fun....because I set up my own clinic and the price was low and I thought it would help my breeder to have another clear scan in her lineage. It was a few months before his annual vaccines and check up so this was the first time he'd had his heart listened to since 5 months old. His murmur was signifigant, grade 4/5 and his echo revealed severe HCM. I was told to start atenolol immediately and that he would start passing out soon without meds. That's at just 1yr old. If anyone says scans at 1yr are also useless....they aren't.

After a month on atenolol I took Count to a new local vet and she listened to his heart. she told me he had a mild murmur and not to worry about it. WFT? I informed her of his severe HOCM, his echo results and meds and she told me I jumped the gun on meds and I didn't need to worry about the murmur. That is scary!!! How many other cats with murmurs has she listened to and said don't worry about it?? she didn't recommend an echo either. She also didn't take into consideration he was on atenolol for a month so his murmur would be decreased a bit because his meds are working.

So I rambled all that to you to illustrate that listening to the heart is great, and you may have good news when you get a scan that it is a benign murmur....but you really do need a scan at 1yr to figure out if its benign or not and there are some nutty vets out there telling people that severe murmurs are nothing to worry about and don't need scans.....AND both my cats showed no symptoms of HCM so don't let them tell you you don't need a scan cause he doesn't have symptoms. The benefit of a scan is it will either ease your mind and tell you its benign, or its hcm and you get him on meds that will buy you extra time. Heart meds are not expensive at all btw. Just the scan is costly and usually annual with a HCM positive cat.

Would the breeder agree to pay for his scan at 1yr of age, or split it with you? You are taking a big risk emotionally and financially and doing her a favor really....I don't expect her to cover future scans or meds, but what about the first??

I'm so sorry to hear about count and nofuratu. Unfortunately she isn't willing to scan him at all. Not even if she keeps him herself. She doesn't see the need in having a $500 test done for a give away cat :sad: if anything I just want to rescue this boy and give him the biggest chance in life. Her decisions have made me doubt my choice in breeder. She scans her cats before they start breeding. That's it. No other follow ups. I've already paid for my kit. And have fallen for her deeply so I will still get her is just made me rethink a lot.
 

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
Oh I forgot to mention. Our girl is getting desexed at 1kg or 10 weeks old. Yoda was desexed when I got him also at 10 weeks old. The little boy is weighing in at 1.3kg at 13 weeks. The very seems to be taking extra precautions not wanting to loose my breeders business. In casesomething happens while he's under.
Hubby is willing to take him on now, but not in 3 months time. Thinking it will disturb the routine which we will have in place. Also considering he'll be older, worry that Yoda and Iris won't take a new addition well.
Hopefully she can work something out soon. So we can take on both babies but it's just the waiting game now
 

Nofuratu

V.I.P Lairian
V.I.P Lairian
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
1,659
Points
238
I'm so sorry to hear about count and nofuratu. Unfortunately she isn't willing to scan him at all. Not even if she keeps him herself. She doesn't see the need in having a $500 test done for a give away cat :sad: if anything I just want to rescue this boy and give him the biggest chance in life. Her decisions have made me doubt my choice in breeder. She scans her cats before they start breeding. That's it. No other follow ups. I've already paid for my kit. And have fallen for her deeply so I will still get her is just made me rethink a lot.

wow. I don't blame you for rethinking. breeding cats need annual scans. That is worrisome. And splitting the bill on a scan for this cat, which means the breeder coughing up $250 say, to give her cat a good home.....disappointing. You want a breeder that cares more about the breeding program than profit. Im not saying she has to go broke....hope everything works out for you and you don't have issues with the breeder later. it is a tough decision for you!!
 

toasty

Senior Lairian
Senior Lairian
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
371
Points
78
wow. I don't blame you for rethinking. breeding cats need annual scans. That is worrisome. And splitting the bill on a scan for this cat, which means the breeder coughing up $250 say, to give her cat a good home.....disappointing. You want a breeder that cares more about the breeding program than profit. Im not saying she has to go broke....hope everything works out for you and you don't have issues with the breeder later. it is a tough decision for you!!

I hope it does too. I'm now worried about my lil girl. She says that this is the first time she has ever had a kitten with a murmur.
She is taking the little guy to yet another vet, this one recommended by another breeder for an assessment. Hopefully he can be desexed and can come and live with us soon. So he coen get all the love and medical attention he needs. I have spoken to my vet about him. He recommended having him scanned at 12 months. He said there isn't too much we can do before then.
 
Back
Top