- Joined
- Jan 16, 2011
- Messages
- 37,595
- Points
- 673
Not sure @Fester. I guess it could go both ways. My vet was very pleased to hear we were giving it before he recommended it and being it is not a money maker for him since I do not purchase through them I looked at it as more positive thing than negative. But it is considered a supplement...if supplements were not beneficial then humans would not take them. Granted some "supplements" are not really studied and there is no solid study that I know of with actual results for many supplements for humans or animals...that includes L-Lysine.
After what felt like never ending respiratory issues after our last kitten, I finally got things under control months later after they passed it back and forth. I feel like I do not want to take any chances of reoccurrence. If I miss a day I do not freak but I will tell you one thing I was totally freaking when they were ill...lol!
Now you are making me think this thing through even more (you always have thought provoking comments) we have seen several on here not on antibiotics and L-Lysine has helped them and not all were herpes related. We do not have any that have shared they just stopped mid stream to see if it no longer worked that I know of. But to your point, do I feel like mine would fall ill again without it, no...but as supplement is supposed to help give a boost and for that reason I continue...as well as my vet saying it is a positive thing.
Hope that makes sense. I do not look at it as a cure...just as maintenance...and so far so good...knock on wood. Last comment...I think this forum is filled with some very breed specific success and it has seemed to be a positive for many members, so I guess we have our own little study going on...lol. Not sure it will ever be quantifiable and that can always open the door for the unknown. I am copying @admin on this as Tom is always full of information.
patti
After what felt like never ending respiratory issues after our last kitten, I finally got things under control months later after they passed it back and forth. I feel like I do not want to take any chances of reoccurrence. If I miss a day I do not freak but I will tell you one thing I was totally freaking when they were ill...lol!
Now you are making me think this thing through even more (you always have thought provoking comments) we have seen several on here not on antibiotics and L-Lysine has helped them and not all were herpes related. We do not have any that have shared they just stopped mid stream to see if it no longer worked that I know of. But to your point, do I feel like mine would fall ill again without it, no...but as supplement is supposed to help give a boost and for that reason I continue...as well as my vet saying it is a positive thing.
Hope that makes sense. I do not look at it as a cure...just as maintenance...and so far so good...knock on wood. Last comment...I think this forum is filled with some very breed specific success and it has seemed to be a positive for many members, so I guess we have our own little study going on...lol. Not sure it will ever be quantifiable and that can always open the door for the unknown. I am copying @admin on this as Tom is always full of information.
patti